Philadelphia Zoo Guards Smelled Smoke, but Did Nothing About It

Employees at the Philadelphia Zoo smelled smoke nearly three hours before a fire that killed 23 primates was reported, but they did nothing, officials said today.

"The fire was going for at least three hours before we ever got called," the Fire Commissioner, Harold Hairston, said at a news conference.

Officials also cited faulty construction and a fire alarm that did not function as contributing to Saturday's fire.

Two guards smelled smoke near the zoo's World of Primates about 10 P.M. on Saturday, "but they dismissed it because they didn't see anything," Commissioner Hairston said. The Fire Department was called 2 hours 40 minutes later, when guards spotted flames shooting from the primate building. By then, the animals were dead, Mr. Hairston said.

Asked if the animals might have survived if fire officials had been alerted immediately, the Commissioner had a one-word answer, "Yeah."

The fire killed 6 prized West African lowland gorillas, 3 Bornean orangutans, 4 white-handed gibbons and 10 lemurs. Zoo employees got another reason for dismay this week when an examination showed that one gorilla was pregnant.

The fire started on or near an improperly installed electrical insulating wire that ringed a water pipe above a wooden ceiling in the decade-old structure, Commissioner Hairston said. The wire insulated the pipe and kept the water from freezing.

"What we found was an improper wrap" of the wire around the pipe that caused the ceiling to become dry and more flammable over time, he said.

Although the building was equipped with smoke detectors and alarms, there is no indication the alarms ever sounded.

Commissioner Hairston said the alarms, which are on the top of the 70-by-200-foot primate exhibit, were partly filled with snow, but he added that at least a muffled sound should have been audible if everything was working properly.

The system, he said, did work during its quarterly test in September.

The Commissioner said the guards told fire investigators that they had mistakenly believed the smoke they smelled was from fires that are often burning in a nearby railroad yard.

Neither Commissioner Hairston nor the zoo's president, Alexander L. Hoskins, would identify the guards.

Mr. Hoskins said that he planned to review of guards' actions before making any decision about disciplinary action. "It's easy to assume human error," he said, "but I am very careful about making what I would call a scapegoat in this case."

Commissioner Hairston said he had several recommendations for the zoo. The most important training the Fire Department will provide, he said, will be to teach zoo staff "to use 911 to call us."

At least $100,000 of the zoo's $1.2 million capital budget for this year is designated for improving security and fire protection.

The fire has caused deep anguish among zookeepers and members of the public who have responded with donations that Mr. Hoskins estimated at $100,000. The zoo plans a monthlong memorial to honor the animals, all of which were members of endangered species.

 

Philadelphia Zoo Fire Is Tied to Heating Cable

The fire that left 23 primates dead of smoke inhalation at the Philadelphia Zoo last December was caused by an improperly installed heating cable in the roof of their quarters, not by questionable actions of guards that night, zoo officials said today.

In presenting the results of two internal investigations -- one by zoo staff members, the other by zoo board members -- the officials said the reports agreed with the major findings of the Philadelphia Fire Department's investigation, announced last month, that the fire "was accidental in nature," resulting from the cable's igniting the wood ceiling and wall supports in the World of Primates building, and that the zoo's security and fire detection systems were working properly at the time.

The two guards on duty that night, Dec. 23, were dismissed in January. But at a midday news conference to discuss the zoo investigations, Alexander Hoskins, the zoo president, emphasized that they were let go solely for not performing their duties that night.

"The guards are not being blamed for the fire," Mr. Hoskins said.

With yet another investigation under way, by the zoo's insurance company, which plans to study the heating system and interview those involved with its design and construction, zoo officials did not suggest who, if anyone, might ultimately be blamed for the fire.

The blaze caused the worst known loss of animal life at a zoo in history and cast a pall over the city during the Christmas season. The primates that died included the zoo's entire family of six gorillas, all three of its orangutans, all four white-handed gibbons and 10 lemurs, some of them exceedingly rare.

Almost right away, donations began pouring in to help the zoo replace the animals and the 10-year-old building where they lived. Through today, the zoo has received more than $1.2 million in private donations as a result of the fire, and Duke University has promised the zoo 12 lemurs. Mr. Hoskins said that some of the lemurs could be on display by summer, but that rebuilding permanent quarters could take years.

While the deaths of the primates have elicited financial support and sympathy for the zoo, the oldest in the country and the second-most popular attraction in Philadelphia after the Liberty Bell, they have also sparked widespread criticism of zoo officials for circumstances that apparently contributed to the fire. According to the Fire Department report, these circumstances included the improper installation of a heat trace cable, a mechanism that prevents freezing of liquids in pipes, and its apparent lack of maintenance because of inaccessibility.

Zoo officials have also been questioned about the guards' apparent lax behavior that night. All three investigations determined that the guards did not respond after they said they smelled something burning around 10 P.M. and that they notified the Fire Department only after they discovered the fire, about 12:44 A.M.

In summarizing the zoo's two investigations, Mr. Hoskins said that the guards had access to a control board in a nearby building that would have pinpointed the source of the smoke, but that they did not check it. He also said the guards falsified logs to indicate they had made a final round of the primate area near the end of their shift.

One of the dismissed guards, Edith Henry, who had worked at the zoo for seven years, told The Philadelphia Inquirer last week that the guards' cellular telephones did not work, that guards had no keys to the room where the control board was located, and that critical parts of the alarm system malfunctioned.

"We are very much able to challenge all those assertions," Mr. Hoskins said. "I am confident she is not correct."

A lawyer Ms. Henry has consulted, Robert W. Sink of Blue Bell, Pa., said in an interview that she sought legal help because she was not a member of a union. He said he was evaluating her case and had not decided whether he would represent her.

The other guard, Joe Villaloz, a zoo employee for 17 years, is a member of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, which has filed a wrongful dismissal grievance against the zoo on Mr. Villaloz's behalf.

Thomas Cronin, president of Mr. Villaloz's local, said that zoo officials were unfairly blaming the guards when the investigations have shown a variety of mechanical problems. "If they expect people to believe that the breakdown of all those systems was the fault of two low-paid guards," Mr. Cronin said, "then I have a ski shop in Kuwait."

 

 

Zoo Officials Assess Damage To Primate Gene Pool by Fire

Many of the melancholy bouquets delivered to the Philadelphia Zoo this week are adorned with little bananas and apples, symbolic gifts to the 23 gorillas and gibbons, lemurs and orangutans that perished on Christmas Eve in the country's worst calamity for zoo animals.

Not quite human, the simian families that perished from a smoky fire have left behind not only an aching grief, but also potentially irreparable holes in the gene pool for the country's primate population.

I cannot think of anything comparable to this loss in North America," said Kevin Willis, a conservation biologist at the American Zoo and Aquarium Association, the agency that will oversee the arduous task of combing the genetic markers of primate populations at other collections to see if replacements can be found for Philadelphia's lost animals.

"Miami lost a lot of birds in Hurricane Andrew, but only one mammal died," Mr. Willis went on. "We lost some valuable birds in St. Louis when a heat lamp melted the insulation, there was a brush fire that ran all the way up to the perimeter fence at the San Diego Zoo a while ago. But nothing has happened like this before."

The lost animals died before dawn on Dec. 24 from the smoke of a smoldering fire in the roof of the World of Primates building. They were among the Philadelphia Zoo's 110 primates, simians that share their taxonomic order with humans.

The zoo's entire family of six gorillas, including a male and two females, which in 1967 were among the last wild-born low-country gorillas to be brought from the wilds into the United States, two of their infants and an unborn fetus, which the zoo counts as an individual, were all lost in the fire.

The smoke also took all three of the zoo's Bornean orangutans, including Rita, an all but irreplaceable wild-born female, all four white-handed gibbons, all six ring-tailed lemurs, both ruffed lemurs and two of six mongoose lemurs.

Replacing these animals, if it can be done, is no longer a matter of safaris into the jungle with nets and cages, as depicted by the British conservationist Gerald Durrell in the 1950's, said Andrew J. Baker, curator of primates and small mammals at the zoo.

To replace their lost primates, the zoo will apply to the Species Survival Program committees of the zoo association, each of which keeps complete genealogical records for an endangered or protected specimen in the United States and Canada. Those designations are set by various international agreements.

The committee records rank each captive animal according to its potential contribution to the gene pool's diversity, with the highest value accorded to wild-born specimens without offspring and the lowest to an animal with many siblings and cousins in collections elsewhere.

Each Species Survival Program committee of zoologists controls the breeding and distribution to insure that the captive population's genetic composition remains as diverse as possible. The system was first developed in 1908, to rebuild the North American buffalo herd from a handful of founders, Mr. Willis noted.

"Ironically, Philadelphia has a new pair of ruffed lemurs from Madagascar already waiting in quarantine, and the pair they lost was going to be sent to the Phoenix Zoo," said Ingrid Porton, a curator at the St. Louis Zoo and the Coordinator, or head, of the Ruffed Lemurs Species Survival Program.

"So the ruffed lemurs Philadelphia lost are already replaced, but I'll have to find another pair for Phoenix now," Dr. Porton said.

The Philadelphia Zoo is the country's oldest, and the loss has evoked grief and remorse among the zookeepers. The zoo has hired counselors from Jewish Family and Children's Services in the city to help the animals keepers, many of whom raised the lost animals from infancy, deal with the loss.

Two security guards at the zoo were suspended on Thursday morning pending investigations into the cause of the fire by the zoo's board and by its staff. The guards smelled smoke at the zoo late on Dec. 23 but did nothing for more than 2 1/2 hours, a spokeswoman for the zoo, Antoinette Maciolek, said.

The guards told fire officials earlier in the week that they had thought the smoke was from a fire at a nearby railroad yard. Fire investigators also faulted improperly installed wiring and smoke alarms that did not work.

The zoo was kept closed over the Christmas week, but will reopen on Tuesday and no admission will be charged for the month as an expression of gratitude for the concern and sympathy of city residents. A memorial exhibit for the animals will be created.

On a purely scientific basis, said Mr. Willis of the zoo association, the loss of the two mongoose lemurs represents the greatest potential depletion of the stock, because only 48 were in captivity in the United States and Canada, and the male was ranked second in terms of genetic scarcity.

There are 248 ruffed lemurs and 403 ring-tailed lemurs in other collections, with many relatives to the ones lost here, so the fire did not represent a great loss for that species, Mr. Willis said.

Not so, he added, for the loss of the three Bornean orangutans, Rita and her daughter Jingga.

"That was an important pair, Mr. Willis said. "They were ranked right at the top. There were 95 of them in North America, so numerically it not as big a loss as the mongoose lemurs, but genetically, this was a terrible loss for the population because the mother was born in the wild."

There are 321 low-land gorillas in the United States and Canada, Mr. Willis went on, so the loss of the loss of the six will not deplete the size of the population unduly, particularly since the three adults had sent four more offspring to the Bronx Zoo and to zoos in Columbus, Washington and San Diego.

Yet, the gorillas were distinct, not just for the place they held as the Philadelphia Zoo's most popular family, but because the group had been so stable, Dr. Baker, the primate curator, said. "They had been together all their lives, with the only additions coming for births," he said.

Zoo personnel are also beginning to measure how long they will feel the sting of loss.

"Its not going to end for us soon," Ms. Maciolek said. "We wait all winter long to hear Rita and Jingga hooting in the trees again, because that means it's spring. We open our windows and say, 'Listen!' That's going to hurt come springtime because they won't be there."